From Booklist:
PreS-Gr. 2. A clever variation on Stone Soup / Nail Soup, this Dutch import hits the nail squarely on the head. "Kate kept a tidy house and a weeded garden and she never shared her vegetables with anyone!" Then an unkempt giant, Bruce, builds a ramshackle house next door. Kate is disdainful of his dandelion tea (it's just weeds) and of his invitation to go fishing, replying that he should do something useful instead. When a raging storm blows his atrocious house away, Kate brings Bruce home, admonishing him not to eat her food. "Of course not," he replies, offering to make hammer soup, which needs nails and bolts--though he allows that her sausages and carrots will do. The artwork is sprightly and colorful, filled with amusing details, including a cat and a dog that play comical roles in the background. The visual contrast between Kate (in a tall, yellow hat; tights; and a long, black braid), and much larger, messier Bruce effectively demonstrates that sometimes opposites can become friends. Endpapers decorated with vegetables and an occasional tool add an appropriate note of whimsy. Julie Cummins
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
From School Library Journal:
PreSchool-Grade 3–Through a combination of classic themes and wonderfully detailed, quirky watercolors, this oft-told tale comes to life. Hardworking Kate is neat and tidy, and her garden is well tended, but she does not like to share. Bruce the giant builds a lopsided, rickety shack next door, and he would much rather spend his time fishing and playing than getting ready for winter. When the harsh weather comes, his house is blown away and he loses everything. Kate opens her house to him, but with the reminder that he may not share her food. His solution is to make soup from water, salt, and a hammer. He says it would be delicious if he only had some nails and bolts, but sausage and vegetables could be used in a pinch (sound familiar?). Children will delight in the whimsical illustrations as well as in the humor of this book; although the story would be a great read-aloud, the details in the paintings beg to be pored over up close.–Genevieve Gallagher, Orange County Public Library, VA
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
"About this title" may belong to another edition of this title.